Introduction
Who Said I Would” has an interesting history within Phil Collins’s discography. While many associate it with his live performances, the song was originally recorded for his highly successful 1985 album, “No Jacket Required.” However, it wasn’t released as a single at that time.
“No Jacket Required” was a defining moment in Collins’s solo career, solidifying his status as a global pop superstar. The album spawned numerous hit singles, including “Sussudio” and “One More Night,” which dominated the charts worldwide. Amidst these chart-toppers, “Who Said I Would” remained an album track, showcasing a slightly different side to Collins’s musical style.
The song’s lyrics explore a complex relationship dynamic, portraying a sense of emotional detachment and uncertainty. The narrator grapples with a partner who seems unwilling to commit fully, responding to any suggestion of future involvement with the dismissive phrase, “Who said I would?” This theme of emotional unavailability resonates with many listeners, contributing to the song’s enduring appeal.
It wasn’t until 1991 that “Who Said I Would” finally received its single release. This came from his live album, “Serious Hits… Live!”, which captured the energy and excitement of his live performances. The live version showcased a more dynamic and energetic rendition of the song, highlighting Collins’s skills as a performer and his band’s musical prowess. This live release introduced the song to a wider audience and even saw it chart in the US, reaching number 73 on the Billboard Hot 100. This unusual trajectory, from album track to live single, has given “Who Said I Would” a unique place in Phil Collins’s musical history.