Introduction
Phil Collins’ Former Bandmates Speak Out — Honest Reflections on the Legendary Drummer
Over the decades, Phil Collins has become one of the most recognizable figures in music, known for his unforgettable voice, legendary drumming, and solo success. But what do those closest to him — his former bandmates — really think about him? In recent interviews, members of Genesis and his longtime collaborators have opened up, revealing candid and heartfelt opinions about Collins, his talent, and his impact on their lives.
Tony Banks, Genesis’ keyboardist and founding member, recently shared in a BBC interview, “Phil has always been the heart of the band, not just as a drummer but as a frontman. People forget how reluctant he was to take the lead after Peter Gabriel left. But once he stepped up, everything changed. He brought energy, honesty, and a human connection that people felt instantly.”
Guitarist Mike Rutherford also praised Collins’ commitment to the band, especially during the turbulent transition years in the late 1970s. “Phil was never about ego,” Rutherford said. “Even when his solo career exploded, he stayed grounded with Genesis. He could have left us after Face Value, but he stayed. That loyalty meant everything.”
Of course, working together for decades wasn’t without challenges. The bandmates have admitted there were tough moments, particularly as Collins’ solo fame sometimes overshadowed the group. “We had disagreements, like any band,” Banks confessed. “But we always respected each other. Phil had this incredible ability to switch between mega pop star and just ‘one of the guys’ when we were recording.”
Chester Thompson, who toured with Genesis as their live drummer for many years, has described Collins as a “drummer’s drummer.” He said, “Phil’s timing, his feel, it’s instinctive. People see the hits, but they don’t always realize how technically brilliant he is as a musician.”
During the band’s final tour in 2021-2022, many fans noticed how emotional the remaining Genesis members were. Behind the scenes, it was reportedly Phil’s determination to perform despite his declining health that impressed his bandmates the most. “He was in pain, but he wanted to be there for the fans and for us,” Rutherford remarked. “That kind of dedication is rare.”
While some earlier reports had hinted at tensions within the group, recent interviews have painted a picture of mutual admiration and lasting friendship. Phil’s bandmates have expressed concern over his health struggles, but they also remain proud of the legacy they built together. “We’ve had our disagreements,” Banks said, “but Phil’s contribution to music — to Genesis, to pop, to rock — is undeniable.”
Whether it’s his musical genius, his work ethic, or his kindness behind the scenes, Collins’ former bandmates continue to speak of him with great respect. As Tony Banks summed it up: “There will never be another Phil Collins. And we’re lucky we had him.”