Introduction
“Who Said I Would” is a dynamic and energetic track by Phil Collins, originally featured on his highly successful 1985 album No Jacket Required. While not initially released as a single from that album, it gained significant popularity when a live version was released in 1991 as a single from his live album, Serious Hits… Live! This live rendition is the one most commonly associated with the song and is the focus here.
The song is driven by a powerful drumbeat, a prominent bassline, and a catchy keyboard melody, creating a vibrant and upbeat atmosphere. It also features a notable saxophone solo, adding a touch of soulful flair. Lyrically, “Who Said I Would” is about defying expectations and refusing to conform to others’ opinions or limitations. It’s a declaration of independence and self-determination, with Collins asserting his right to pursue his own path.
The live version from Serious Hits… Live! captures the energy and excitement of Collins’s live performances. It showcases his charismatic stage presence and his ability to connect with an audience. The song’s infectious rhythm and uplifting message make it a crowd favorite, and the live recording perfectly encapsulates this dynamic. The performance features tight instrumentation from his backing band, including Daryl Stuermer on guitar and Chester Thompson on drums, as well as the Phenix Horns, who add a powerful punch to the song’s arrangement.
The decision to release a live version of “Who Said I Would” as a single proved to be a successful one, further solidifying the song’s place in Collins’s repertoire. It reached number 73 on the Billboard Hot 100 in the United States, demonstrating its enduring appeal even years after its initial release. The live version remains a popular choice for radio airplay and is often included in compilations of Collins’s greatest hits, testament to its enduring popularity and energetic live performance.